Author (#1)March 2005 Archives

How computers cause bad writing

|

Gerard Grow's Website: Biggest writing problems caused by computers are: people editing rather than rethinking; the confusion caused by "collaborative writing" where people rewrite each others material; and the temptation to reuse blocks of text from other works.

NY Times -- Can Papers End the Free Ride Online?. As mentioned earlier this year, the NY Times is considering charging for access to its site. Today's article says the plan will be announced soon (many predictions of an April announcement). Whether to charge or not is an issues facing many newspapers, these days. Online advertising is growing and spending for other online services, such as music downloads, is growing, at a rapid rate. But newspapers that charges will lose a large amount of page views, and online advertising revenue.

Perhaps the biggest obstacle for newspapers is that online readers have been conditioned to expect free news. "Most newspapers believe that if they charged for the Web, the number of users would decline to such an extent that their advertising revenues would decline more than they get from charging users," said Gary B. Pruitt, chairman and chief executive of the McClatchy Company, which publishes The Sacramento Bee, The Star Tribune in Minneapolis and other papers, which do not charge for their Web sites.

After the NY Times piece, Ken Sands, online publisher of The Spokesman-Review in Spokane, Wash., posted a good response to the story on the Online News discussion list. Susan Mernit posted his replay, including:

(w)e really have no choice but to look for a better business model. If print circulation and advertising drop significantly, there's probably no way an increase in online revenue can make up the difference. Who's going to pay all of the reporters and editors? Maybe those of us who are left in the future will simply aggregate and edit the news that's provided by citizen journalists. I don't pretend to have all of the answers, but you can't say we aren't looking...",

This week, The Project for Excellence in Journalism made its second annual report on The State of the News Media.

Intro from the overview

Today, technology is transforming citizens from passive consumers of news produced by professionals into active participants who can assemble their own journalism from disparate elements. As people "Google" for information, graze across an infinite array of outlets, read blogs or write them, they are becoming their own editors, researchers, and even correspondents. What was called journalism is only one part of the mix, and its role as intermediary and verifier, like the roles of other civic institutions, is weakening. We are witnessing the rise of a new and more active kind of American citizenship - with new responsibilities that are only beginning to be considered.
Five Major Trends:
> There are now several models of journalism, and the trajectory increasingly is toward those that are faster, looser, and cheaper.
> The rise in partisanship of news consumption and the notion that people have retreated to their ideological corners for news has been widely exaggerated.
> To adapt, journalism may have to move in the direction of making its work more transparent and more expert, and of widening the scope of its searchlight.
> Despite the new demands, there is more evidence than ever that the mainstream media are investing only cautiously in building new audiences.
> The three broadcast network news divisions face their most important moment of transition in decades.


Audience

In a sense, news consumption today should probably be viewed in the way diet is viewed in this age of plentiful, fast and often processed American food. The array of offerings is so vast and varied, being concerned mainly with what is offered seems futile; the proper concern may involve educating consumers about what they should imbibe.

The real crisis may be news obesity, consuming too little that can nourish citizens and too much that can bloat them.

Economics

The question is not whether online advertising will continue to grow, but whether it will ever be big enough to supply the resources to newsrooms we have come to think of as sufficient for quality journalism - and whether it will flow to the organizations that produce journalism, or to those that simply aggregate and pass it on. Will newsgathering organizations that produce what is on the Web benefit, or will processors like Google or Yahoo?

For online journalism to thrive ultimately, some people believe a combined subscription and advertising model for the medium will be necessary. A few outlets are beginning to explore the possibility of bundling sources, as occurs in cable, so that consumers would pay a fee to both the Internet provider for access and to those who create the content.

Consumers are still resistant to paying for Internet journalism, and experiments in 2004 were not promising. If no model is found to monetize the Web to approach the kinds of profit levels of older sectors, the impact could drastically affect the resources available for newsgathering.

News Investment

Some 62% of Web professionals say their newsrooms have seen cutbacks in the last three years - despite huge increases in audiences online. That number is far bigger than the 37% of national print, radio and TV journalists who cited cutbacks in their newsrooms. Anecdotally, Web journalists say what investment there is tends to be in technology for processing information, not in journalists to gather news.

It is part of a larger trend in American journalism: much of the investment and effort is in repackaging and presenting information, not in gathering it. For all that the number of outlets has grown, the number of people engaged in collecting original information has not. Americans are frankly more likely to see the same pictures across multiple TV channels or read the same wire story in different venues than they were a generation ago.


Public Attitudes

Americans do not resent the sense of professional ethics or the aspirations or independence of the press. Rather, they feel journalism is not living up to those goals. They increasingly think the press as a whole is motivated by money and individual journalists by personal ambition.

Conclusion

A year ago, we saw in the larger trends something of a vicious cycle partly of the press's own making.

As audiences declined, because of technological and cultural changes, news organizations felt pressure on revenues and stock performance. In response, they cut back on their newsrooms, squeezed in more advertising and cut back on the percentage of space devoted to news. They tried to respond to changing tastes, too, by lightening their content. Audiences appeared to gravitate to lighter topics, and those topics were often cheaper to cover. Those changes, in turn, deepened the sense that the news media were motivated by economics and less focused on professionalism and the public interest.

In 2005, the sense that the press's role in relation to the public is changing seems ever clearer. A generation ago, the press was effectively a lone institution communicating between the citizenry and the newsmakers, whether corporations selling goods or politicians selling agendas, who wanted to shape public opinion for their own purposes. Today, a host of new forms of communication offer a way for newsmakers to reach the public. There are talk-show hosts, cable interview shows, corporate Web sites, government Web sites, Web sites that purport to be citizen blogs but are really something else, and more. Journalism is a shrinking part of a growing world of media. And since journalists are trained to be skeptics and aspire at least, in the famous phrase, to speak truth to power, journalism is the one source those who want to manipulate the public are most prone to denounce. The atmosphere for journalism, in other words, has become, as the legendary editor John Siegenthaler recently put it, "acidic."

The challenge for traditional journalism is whether it can reassert its position as the provider of something distinctive and valuable - both for citizens and advertisers. The press continues to thrive financially because, while the audience collected in any one place may be smaller, it is still the largest venue available to advertisers. The trend lines, however, make clear that this, too, should not be taken for granted. Somehow journalism needs to prove that it is acting on behalf of the public, if it is to save itself.


The overall report includes in-depth looks at major news media groups, including newspapers, online and various divisions of TV.

Reflections on the report from: Dan Gillmor and Terry Heaton

Coping in the modern world

|

NY Times -- No Need to Stew: A Few Tips to Cope with Life's Annoyances:

"They're an integral part of how people cope," said Prof. James C. Scott, who teaches anthropology and political science at Yale University, and the author of "Weapons of the Weak," about the feigned ignorance, foot-dragging and other techniques Malaysian peasants used to avoid cooperating with the arrival of new technology in the 1970's. "All societies have them, but they're successful only to the extent that they avoid open confrontation."

* Buzzworthy -- Blog Summit reflections. Brian Chin lists his highlights from a Blog Business Summit from January. including ways to make a business from blogging, talking to bloggers, blogging as just a communications technology and that blogging is still no substitute for meeting people in person. Brian also wrote of earlier impressions about the summit

* Problogger -- Interview with Glenn Fleishman. Glenn, who has blogged for several years, is interviewed about Entrepreneurial Blogging, trying to make a business out of blogging. He also presented at the Blog Business Summit.

* USA Today -- Google's AdSense a bonanza for some Web sites looks at how AdSense is paying some bloggers more than the cost of the hosting service. Yahoo! will compete against AdSense with its new service expected to be announced this week, according to several media, including CNET.

* AdSense Secrets -- What Google never told you about Making Money with AdSense. -- New book tell you to earn five-figure income with AdSense. PDF version costs only $99. Tip from Lockergnome, with a testimonial from Chris Pirillo.

* Washington Post -- Make Money off Your Blog mentions AdSense, BlogAds, and some self-run ideas.

Atlanta Business Chronicle -- The man behind Rathergate: Atlanta attorney, the blogger 'Buckhead,' first discredited anchor's report

Atlanta Business Chronicle -- Federal prisoners going to work

Milwaukee Business Journal -- No health coverage? No degree: More colleges requiring students to enroll in health care plans

Nashville Business Journal -- Local Publix store to sell gasoline

My car wish list

|

2005 Honda Accord, reviewed by Forbes. Also Accord was top pick by Consumer Reports.

Propaganda or video news release?

|

NY Times -- Under Bush, a New Age of Prepackaged Television News. The government has made for several years video press releases where they hire people to perform interviews and package the material like interviews.

Video releases were started under the Clinton administration and continues with the Bush administration. Segments are sent to TV stations. At this point there's little difference between video and traditional press release.

Many corporations also do this Medialink Worldwide Inc. is a major business in this industry, according to the article.

TV stations air the pieces, but do they let viewers know this is a prepared piece by the interested party? Too often they don't. There's where the foul occurs. Readers or viewers can decide the credibility of the material shown, just let them know the source of the information.

It's a lengthy article, but it's great reading when the news directors try to explain or don't bother explaining why they showed the segments without letting viewers know the source. Also the need to cut costs at local television stations make video press releases a tempting solution in filling the need for material.

Encouraging us to save

|

NY Times -- Savings: Lots of Talk, but Few Dollars

Personal savings have declined fairly steadily for more than two decades, even as tax incentives for savings have proliferated. According to a recent analysis by Elizabeth Bell, Adam Carasso and C. Eugene Steuerle at the Urban Institute, the federal government now spends more on tax breaks for retirement savings than Americans actually save.

and

By contrast, one of the hottest ideas in Washington grows out of new research on the behavior of savers. Recent studies by researchers at the Wharton School of Business and Harvard showed that employee contributions to 401(k) plans soared at companies that automatically enrolled employees and gave them a chance to opt out.

An e-commerce paradox

|

red_teapot.jpg I can order this teakettle from Target.com at anytime of the day, but it takes seven weeks to ship it to me.



CNET --FAQ: Blogging on the job. "Being a blogger can get you in trouble nowadays, at least if you write something that sufficiently vexes your employer."

From Tim Bray, technology director at Sun Microsystems: Ten Reasons Why Blogging is Good For Your Career. "For most people, blogging is a career-booster, both in your current job and when you’re looking for your next one."

WSJ -- Blogs Expose Personal Finance: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly. Looks at browing field of personal finance blogs

What really struck me about many of these blogs, and the people behind them, was the level of sensitive financial information they were willing to reveal. In the "real world," people tend to jealously guard the intimate details of their financial lives: What you earn, how much you've saved, what you owe is viewed as so personal that many are unwilling to share the details with anyone -- occasionally even their spouses.

Baltimore Sun -- Roth 401(k) beckons for many workers next year. Next year, many employers are expected to add a modified Roth 401(k).

Fidelity -- Fidelity Survey Provides Real-Time Look at the Retirement Readiness of Today's Recent Retirees "Although many recent retirees (66%) report that they are living the lifestyle that they had hoped in retirement, over half (57%) look back on the years before leaving the workplace and wish they had done more to prepare, according to a new study by Fidelity Investments."

NY Times -- Analyzing the I.Q. of Money. "Walter Hertler, a technical analyst, thinks he has it figured out, and many stock market investors won't like the news.

American Medical News -- Medical costs lead more people to bankruptcy: Most debtors had health insurance when the illness that fueled their financial problems struck. Study from Health Affairs: MarketWatch: Illness And Injury As Contributors To Bankruptcy. "Among those whose illnesses led to bankruptcy, out-of-pocket costs average $11,854 since the start of illness; 75.7 percent had insurance at the onset of illness. Medical debtors were 42 percent more likely than other debtors to experience lapses in coverage. Even middle-class insured families often fall prey to financial catastrophe when sick."

NY Times -- After Writing a Will, You Still Have I's to Dot. "But when people fail to make estate-planning decisions while they are alive and well, the results for their heirs can be costly and stressful."

Why Wikipedia works

|

Wikipedia's reputation is growing, partially in the belief that all its contributors collectively know more than even the staff and contributors of established encyclopedia publishers. Wired looks at a few of those who contribute to Wikipedia, how the contributors police themselves for accuracy and vandalism in The Book Stops Here.

Wired profiled March 8 profiled some of the top "editors" on Wikipedia. Editors are those who contribute and clean up others entries. Some spend hours each day volunteering on the Wikipedia.


College professor Clay Sharkey writes on his reaction to receiving papers where students cite Wikipedia as a source. He says Wikipedia entries are as good as the other encyclopedia entries, but students should still go to the primary sources. Sharkey continues a discussion about Wikipedia with danah. Tip: Brian Chin in buzzworthy

Improving online reading

|

Poynter -- In Search Of: The Best Online Reading Experience. "Reading on a computer brings a new set of design challenges. And it's way more complicated than Gutenberg might have imagined. But the good news is that there's a lot of research being done on this topic."

Article also has preview of new fonts that will debut with Microsoft's Longhorn OS. Another good article from Poynter linked from the article is Eight Things You Can Do Now To Improve On-Screen Readability

Atlanta Business Chronicle -- ChoicePoint's Smith is at a crossroads

Business First of Buffalo -- Maple producers tap into cash crop

Houston Business Journal -- Kidnapping for ransom a rising risk overseas: Insurance costs vary depending on country

Business First of Louisville -- National campaign prompts dialogue on infection rates at hospitals

Biz Demographics: Hartford carries the heaviest economic stress of any large city

Silicon Valley/San Jose Business Journal: Startup uses tiny probes to store data

Los Angeles Business from bizjournals: Bugs and Daffy head to the future

Puget Sound Business Journal: Massive study threatened by vitamin E report scare

Silicon Valley/San Jose Business Journal: Laser chip breakthrough claimed by Intel


Top Entrepreneur/Sales Power stories

Up from nothing: He just wanted a job. He found a business.

Sometimes a great notion: He spent years turning an idea into a business.

From scratch: She learned enough to build her business to $10 million a year.

The turnaround queen: She helps companies rethink how they sell themselves.

Chasing the flames: His business descended from his days shooting video of fires.

NY Times -- You There, at the Computer: Pay Attention. All those cool things to do with a computer, check email, surf a site, IM a friend make concentration difficult. Computer scientists are trying now to decide if the computers themselves could not do a better job of knowing when to interrupt the user or remain still.

NY Times -- For Drivers, a Traffic Jam of Distraction. Laws requiring hands-free cellphone use while driving are expanding, but more research shows its not the use of the hands that causes the distraction, but the conversations. And now the distractions are growing with iPods, wireless hand-held devices and one of the classics, eating in the car.

From Michael Trujillo, an early promoter of hands-free-only cellphone laws while driving, now thinks the bans should be lifted. "If you have hands free, not only are you able to do something else, but you are able to do three different tasks at the same time."